%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : LisaST---0.9
% Problem : CSR115+11 : TPTP v9.3.1. Released v4.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : casc-portfolio.sh -t 300 /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% Computer : n001.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8046.5625MB
% OS : Linux 6.8.0-71-generic
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Sun Sep 27 07:04:39 AM UTC 2026
% Result : Theorem 70.15s 15.94s
% Output : CNFRefutation 70.15s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.00/0.05 % Problem : CSR115+11 : TPTP v9.3.1. Released v4.0.0.
% 0.00/0.06 % Command : casc-portfolio.sh -t 300 /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 0.18/0.44 % Computer : n001.cluster.edu
% 0.18/0.44 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.18/0.44 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.18/0.44 % Memory : 8046.5625MB
% 0.18/0.44 % OS : Linux 6.8.0-71-generic
% 0.18/0.44 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.18/0.44 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.18/0.44 % DateTime : Sun Sep 27 01:12:30 UTC 2026
% 0.18/0.45 % CPUTime :
% 0.18/0.45 Running casc-portfolio.sh -t 300 /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 70.15/15.94 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark.p
% 70.15/15.94 % SZS output start CNFRefutation for theBenchmark.p
% 70.15/15.94 fof(ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109, hypothesis, (sub(c20305,'abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1') & (assoc(c20312,c20305) & (attr(c20312,c20313) & (sub(c20313,'jahr$u$u1$u1') & (val(c20313,c20306) & (attr(c20610,c20611) & (sub(c20610,'firma$u1$u1') & (sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1') & (val(c20611,'bmw$u0') & (attr(c20623,c20624) & (sub(c20623,'mensch$u1$u1') & (sub(c20624,'familiename$u1$u1') & (val(c20624,'roll$u0') & (attr(c20628,c20629) & (cmpl1(c20628,c20623) & (prop(c20628,'britisch$u$u1$u1') & (sub(c20628,'luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1') & (sub(c20629,'eigenname$u1$u1') & (val(c20629,'royce$u0') & (sub(c20630,'abkommen$u1$u1') & (subs(c20640,'anlieferung$u1$u1') & (rslt(c20644,c20649) & (subs(c20644,'entwicklung$u1$u1') & (pred(c20649,'motor$u$u1$u1') & (prop(c20649,'neo$u1$u1') & ('tupl$up7'(c20686,c20312,c20610,c20628,c20630,c20640,c20644) & (assoc('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1','luxus$u$u1$u1') & (assoc('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1','wagen$u2$u1') & (sub('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1','fabrikant$u1$u1') & (sort(c20305,ad) & (sort(c20305,io) & (card(c20305,int1) & (etype(c20305,int0) & (fact(c20305,real) & (gener(c20305,'gener$uc') & (quant(c20305,one) & (refer(c20305,'refer$uc') & (varia(c20305,'varia$uc') & (sort('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1',ad) & (sort('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1',io) & (card('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1',real) & (gener('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1',one) & (refer('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('abschlu$u$u337$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort(c20312,t) & (card(c20312,int1) & (etype(c20312,int0) & (fact(c20312,real) & (gener(c20312,sp) & (quant(c20312,one) & (refer(c20312,det) & (varia(c20312,con) & (sort(c20313,me) & (sort(c20313,oa) & (sort(c20313,ta) & (card(c20313,'card$uc') & (etype(c20313,'etype$uc') & (fact(c20313,real) & (gener(c20313,sp) & (quant(c20313,'quant$uc') & (refer(c20313,'refer$uc') & (varia(c20313,'varia$uc') & (sort('jahr$u$u1$u1',me) & (sort('jahr$u$u1$u1',oa) & (sort('jahr$u$u1$u1',ta) & (card('jahr$u$u1$u1','card$uc') & (etype('jahr$u$u1$u1','etype$uc') & (fact('jahr$u$u1$u1',real) & (gener('jahr$u$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('jahr$u$u1$u1','quant$uc') & (refer('jahr$u$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('jahr$u$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort(c20306,nu) & (card(c20306,int1994) & (sort(c20610,d) & (sort(c20610,io) & (card(c20610,int1) & (etype(c20610,int0) & (fact(c20610,real) & (gener(c20610,sp) & (quant(c20610,one) & (refer(c20610,det) & (varia(c20610,con) & (sort(c20611,na) & (card(c20611,int1) & (etype(c20611,int0) & (fact(c20611,real) & (gener(c20611,sp) & (quant(c20611,one) & (refer(c20611,indet) & (varia(c20611,'varia$uc') & (sort('firma$u1$u1',d) & (sort('firma$u1$u1',io) & (card('firma$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('firma$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('firma$u1$u1',real) & (gener('firma$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('firma$u1$u1',one) & (refer('firma$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('firma$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('name$u1$u1',na) & (card('name$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('name$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('name$u1$u1',real) & (gener('name$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('name$u1$u1',one) & (refer('name$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('name$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('bmw$u0',fe) & (sort(c20623,d) & (card(c20623,int1) & (etype(c20623,int0) & (fact(c20623,real) & (gener(c20623,sp) & (quant(c20623,one) & (refer(c20623,det) & (varia(c20623,con) & (sort(c20624,na) & (card(c20624,int1) & (etype(c20624,int0) & (fact(c20624,real) & (gener(c20624,sp) & (quant(c20624,one) & (refer(c20624,indet) & (varia(c20624,'varia$uc') & (sort('mensch$u1$u1',d) & (card('mensch$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('mensch$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('mensch$u1$u1',real) & (gener('mensch$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('mensch$u1$u1',one) & (refer('mensch$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('mensch$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('familiename$u1$u1',na) & (card('familiename$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('familiename$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('familiename$u1$u1',real) & (gener('familiename$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('familiename$u1$u1',one) & (refer('familiename$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('familiename$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('roll$u0',fe) & (sort(c20628,d) & (card(c20628,int1) & (etype(c20628,int0) & (fact(c20628,real) & (gener(c20628,sp) & (quant(c20628,one) & (refer(c20628,det) & (varia(c20628,con) & (sort(c20629,na) & (card(c20629,int1) & (etype(c20629,int0) & (fact(c20629,real) & (gener(c20629,sp) & (quant(c20629,one) & (refer(c20629,indet) & (varia(c20629,'varia$uc') & (sort('britisch$u$u1$u1',nq) & (sort('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1',d) & (sort('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1',io) & (card('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1',real) & (gener('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1',one) & (refer('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('luxuswagenhersteller$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('eigenname$u1$u1',na) & (card('eigenname$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('eigenname$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('eigenname$u1$u1',real) & (gener('eigenname$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('eigenname$u1$u1',one) & (refer('eigenname$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('eigenname$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('royce$u0',fe) & (sort(c20630,d) & (sort(c20630,io) & (card(c20630,int1) & (etype(c20630,int0) & (fact(c20630,real) & (gener(c20630,sp) & (quant(c20630,one) & (refer(c20630,indet) & (varia(c20630,'varia$uc') & (sort('abkommen$u1$u1',d) & (sort('abkommen$u1$u1',io) & (card('abkommen$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('abkommen$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('abkommen$u1$u1',real) & (gener('abkommen$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('abkommen$u1$u1',one) & (refer('abkommen$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('abkommen$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort(c20640,ad) & (card(c20640,int1) & (etype(c20640,int0) & (fact(c20640,real) & (gener(c20640,sp) & (quant(c20640,one) & (refer(c20640,det) & (varia(c20640,con) & (sort('anlieferung$u1$u1',ad) & (card('anlieferung$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('anlieferung$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('anlieferung$u1$u1',real) & (gener('anlieferung$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('anlieferung$u1$u1',one) & (refer('anlieferung$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('anlieferung$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort(c20644,ad) & (card(c20644,int1) & (etype(c20644,int0) & (fact(c20644,real) & (gener(c20644,sp) & (quant(c20644,one) & (refer(c20644,det) & (varia(c20644,'varia$uc') & (sort(c20649,d) & (card(c20649,cons('x$uconstant',cons(int1,nil))) & (etype(c20649,int1) & (fact(c20649,real) & (gener(c20649,sp) & (quant(c20649,mult) & (refer(c20649,indet) & (varia(c20649,'varia$uc') & (sort('entwicklung$u1$u1',ad) & (card('entwicklung$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('entwicklung$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('entwicklung$u1$u1',real) & (gener('entwicklung$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('entwicklung$u1$u1',one) & (refer('entwicklung$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('entwicklung$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('motor$u$u1$u1',d) & (card('motor$u$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('motor$u$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('motor$u$u1$u1',real) & (gener('motor$u$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('motor$u$u1$u1',one) & (refer('motor$u$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('motor$u$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('neo$u1$u1',nq) & (sort(c20686,ent) & (card(c20686,'card$uc') & (etype(c20686,'etype$uc') & (fact(c20686,real) & (gener(c20686,'gener$uc') & (quant(c20686,'quant$uc') & (refer(c20686,'refer$uc') & (varia(c20686,'varia$uc') & (sort('luxus$u$u1$u1',io) & (card('luxus$u$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('luxus$u$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('luxus$u$u1$u1',real) & (gener('luxus$u$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('luxus$u$u1$u1',one) & (refer('luxus$u$u1$u1','refer$uc') & (varia('luxus$u$u1$u1','varia$uc') & (sort('wagen$u2$u1',da) & (fact('wagen$u2$u1',real) & (gener('wagen$u2$u1',ge) & (sort('fabrikant$u1$u1',d) & (sort('fabrikant$u1$u1',io) & (card('fabrikant$u1$u1',int1) & (etype('fabrikant$u1$u1',int0) & (fact('fabrikant$u1$u1',real) & (gener('fabrikant$u1$u1',ge) & (quant('fabrikant$u1$u1',one) & (refer('fabrikant$u1$u1','refer$uc') & varia('fabrikant$u1$u1','varia$uc')))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))).
% 70.15/15.94 fof(member_first, axiom, ! [X0] : ! [X1] : member(X0,cons(X0,X1))).
% 70.15/15.94 fof(member_second, axiom, ! [X0] : ! [X1] : ! [X2] : ((member(X0,X2) => member(X0,cons(X1,X2))))).
% 70.15/15.94 fof(has_card_eq, axiom, ! [X0] : ! [X1] : ((card(X0,X1) => 'has$ucard$uleq'(X0,X1)))).
% 70.15/15.94 fof(attr_name_hei__337en_1_1, axiom, ! [X0] : ! [X1] : ! [X2] : (((attr(X2,X0) & (member(X1,cons('eigenname$u1$u1',cons('familiename$u1$u1',cons('name$u1$u1',nil)))) & sub(X0,X1))) => ? [X3] : ((arg1(X3,X2) & (arg2(X3,X2) & subs(X3,'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1'))))))).
% 70.15/15.94 fof(hei__337en_1_1__bezeichnen_1_1_als, axiom, ! [X0] : ! [X1] : ! [X2] : (((arg1(X0,X1) & (arg2(X0,X2) & subs(X0,'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1'))) => ? [X3] : ? [X4] : ((arg1(X4,X1) & (arg2(X4,X2) & (hsit(X0,X3) & (mcont(X3,X4) & (obj(X3,X1) & (subr(X4,'rprs$u0') & subs(X3,'bezeichnen$u1$u1'))))))))))).
% 70.15/15.94 fof(synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109, conjecture, ? [X0] : ? [X1] : ? [X2] : ? [X3] : ? [X4] : ? [X5] : ? [X6] : ? [X7] : ((attr(X0,X1) & (attr(X3,X2) & (attr(X5,X6) & ('has$ucard$uleq'(X7,int1994) & (obj(X4,X0) & (sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') & (sub(X0,'firma$u1$u1') & (sub(X2,'name$u1$u1') & (sub(X6,'jahr$u$u1$u1') & (val(X1,'bmw$u0') & (val(X2,'bmw$u0') & val(X6,X7)))))))))))))).
% 70.15/15.94 fof(negated_conjecture, negated_conjecture, ~? [X0] : ? [X1] : ? [X2] : ? [X3] : ? [X4] : ? [X5] : ? [X6] : ? [X7] : ((attr(X0,X1) & (attr(X3,X2) & (attr(X5,X6) & ('has$ucard$uleq'(X7,int1994) & (obj(X4,X0) & (sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') & (sub(X0,'firma$u1$u1') & (sub(X2,'name$u1$u1') & (sub(X6,'jahr$u$u1$u1') & (val(X1,'bmw$u0') & (val(X2,'bmw$u0') & val(X6,X7))))))))))))), inference(negate_conjecture, [status(cth)], [synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c2, plain, attr(c20312,c20313), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c3, plain, sub(c20313,'jahr$u$u1$u1'), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c4, plain, val(c20313,c20306), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c5, plain, attr(c20610,c20611), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c6, plain, sub(c20610,'firma$u1$u1'), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c7, plain, sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1'), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c8, plain, val(c20611,'bmw$u0'), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c76, plain, card(c20306,int1994), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_news_1109])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c275, plain, member(X0,cons(X0,X1)), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [member_first])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c276, plain, ~member(X0,X1) | member(X0,cons(X2,X1)), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [member_second])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c294, plain, ~card(X0,X1) | 'has$ucard$uleq'(X0,X1), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [has_card_eq])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c434, plain, ~attr(X0,X1) | ~member(X2,cons('eigenname$u1$u1',cons('familiename$u1$u1',cons('name$u1$u1',nil)))) | ~sub(X1,X2) | arg1(sK223(X0),X0), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [attr_name_hei__337en_1_1])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c435, plain, ~attr(X0,X1) | ~member(X2,cons('eigenname$u1$u1',cons('familiename$u1$u1',cons('name$u1$u1',nil)))) | ~sub(X1,X2) | arg2(sK223(X0),X0), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [attr_name_hei__337en_1_1])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c436, plain, ~attr(X0,X1) | ~member(X2,cons('eigenname$u1$u1',cons('familiename$u1$u1',cons('name$u1$u1',nil)))) | ~sub(X1,X2) | subs(sK223(X0),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1'), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [attr_name_hei__337en_1_1])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c441, plain, ~arg1(X0,X1) | ~arg2(X0,X2) | ~subs(X0,'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1') | X3(X0,X1,X2), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [hei__337en_1_1__bezeichnen_1_1_als])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c446, plain, ~X0(X1,X2,X3) | obj(sK232(X1,X2,X3),X2), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [hei__337en_1_1__bezeichnen_1_1_als])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(c507, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X1,X0) | ~val(X0,'bmw$u0') | ~sub(X1,'firma$u1$u1') | ~obj(X2,X1) | ~attr(X3,X4) | ~val(X4,'bmw$u0') | ~sub(X4,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X5,X6) | ~val(X6,X7) | ~'has$ucard$uleq'(X7,int1994) | ~sub(X6,'jahr$u$u1$u1'), inference(clausification, [status(esa)], [negated_conjecture])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d0, plain, 'has$ucard$uleq'(c20306,int1994), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c294,c76])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d1, plain, ~sub(X0,X1) | ~attr(X2,X0) | arg1(sK223(X2),X2) | ~member(X1,cons('familiename$u1$u1',cons('name$u1$u1',nil))), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c434,c276])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d2, plain, ~sub(X0,X1) | ~attr(X2,X0) | arg1(sK223(X2),X2) | ~member(X1,cons('name$u1$u1',nil)), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d1,c276])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d3, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X1,X0) | arg1(sK223(X1),X1), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d2,c275])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d4, plain, ~sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1') | arg1(sK223(c20610),c20610), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d3,c5])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d5, plain, arg1(sK223(c20610),c20610), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c7,d4])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d6, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'firma$u1$u1') | ~sub(X2,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X3,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~attr(X4,X0) | ~attr(X1,X2) | ~attr(X5,X3) | ~val(X0,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X2,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X3,X6) | ~'has$ucard$uleq'(X6,int1994) | ~'Ts228'(X7,X1,X8), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c507,c446])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d7, plain, ~sub(X0,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X2,'firma$u1$u1') | ~sub(X3,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X4,X0) | ~attr(X5,X3) | ~attr(X2,X1) | ~val(X0,X6) | ~val(X1,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X3,'bmw$u0') | ~'has$ucard$uleq'(X6,int1994) | ~subs(X7,'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1') | ~arg1(X7,X2) | ~arg2(X7,X8), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d6,c441])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d8, plain, ~sub(X0,X1) | ~attr(X2,X0) | arg2(sK223(X2),X2) | ~member(X1,cons('familiename$u1$u1',cons('name$u1$u1',nil))), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c435,c276])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d9, plain, ~sub(X0,X1) | ~attr(X2,X0) | arg2(sK223(X2),X2) | ~member(X1,cons('name$u1$u1',nil)), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d8,c276])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d10, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X1,X0) | arg2(sK223(X1),X1), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d9,c275])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d11, plain, ~sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1') | arg2(sK223(c20610),c20610), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d10,c5])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d12, plain, arg2(sK223(c20610),c20610), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c7,d11])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d13, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'firma$u1$u1') | ~sub(X2,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X3,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~attr(X4,X0) | ~attr(X5,X3) | ~attr(X1,X2) | ~val(X0,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X2,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X3,X6) | ~subs(sK223(c20610),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1') | ~'has$ucard$uleq'(X6,int1994) | ~arg1(sK223(c20610),X1), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d12,d7])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d14, plain, ~sub(X0,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(c20610,'firma$u1$u1') | ~sub(X2,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X3,X0) | ~attr(X4,X2) | ~attr(c20610,X1) | ~val(X0,X5) | ~val(X1,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X2,'bmw$u0') | ~subs(sK223(c20610),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1') | ~'has$ucard$uleq'(X5,int1994), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d13,d5])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d15, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X2,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~attr(X3,X0) | ~attr(X4,X2) | ~attr(c20610,X1) | ~val(X0,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X1,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X2,X5) | ~subs(sK223(c20610),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1') | ~'has$ucard$uleq'(X5,int1994), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c6,d14])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d16, plain, ~sub(X0,X1) | ~attr(X2,X0) | subs(sK223(X2),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1') | ~member(X1,cons('familiename$u1$u1',cons('name$u1$u1',nil))), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c436,c276])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d17, plain, ~sub(X0,X1) | ~attr(X2,X0) | subs(sK223(X2),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1') | ~member(X1,cons('name$u1$u1',nil)), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d16,c276])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d18, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X1,X0) | subs(sK223(X1),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1'), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d17,c275])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d19, plain, ~sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1') | subs(sK223(c20610),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1'), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d18,c5])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d20, plain, subs(sK223(c20610),'hei$u$u337en$u1$u1'), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c7,d19])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d21, plain, ~sub(X0,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X2,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X3,X0) | ~attr(X4,X2) | ~attr(c20610,X1) | ~val(X0,X5) | ~val(X1,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X2,'bmw$u0') | ~'has$ucard$uleq'(X5,int1994), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d20,d15])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d22, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X2,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~attr(X3,X0) | ~attr(X4,X2) | ~attr(c20610,X1) | ~val(X0,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X1,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X2,c20306), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d21,d0])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d23, plain, ~sub(X0,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X2,X0) | ~attr(X3,c20611) | ~attr(c20610,X1) | ~val(X0,c20306) | ~val(X1,'bmw$u0'), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d22,c8])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d24, plain, ~sub(X0,'name$u1$u1') | ~sub(X1,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~attr(X2,c20611) | ~attr(X3,X1) | ~attr(c20610,X0) | ~val(X0,'bmw$u0') | ~val(X1,c20306), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c7,d23])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d25, plain, ~sub(X0,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X1,X0) | ~attr(X2,c20611) | ~attr(c20610,c20611) | ~val(X0,c20306), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d24,c8])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d26, plain, ~sub(X0,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~sub(c20611,'name$u1$u1') | ~attr(X1,c20611) | ~attr(X2,X0) | ~val(X0,c20306), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c5,d25])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d27, plain, ~sub(X0,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~attr(X1,X0) | ~attr(X2,c20611) | ~val(X0,c20306), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c7,d26])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d28, plain, ~sub(c20313,'jahr$u$u1$u1') | ~attr(X0,c20611) | ~attr(X1,c20313), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d27,c4])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d29, plain, ~attr(X0,c20313) | ~attr(X1,c20611), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [c3,d28])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d30, plain, ~attr(X0,c20611), inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d29,c2])).
% 70.15/15.94 cnf(d31, plain, $false, inference(resolution, [status(thm)], [d30,c5])).
% 70.15/15.94 % SZS output end CNFRefutation for theBenchmark.p
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------