%------------------------------------------------------------------------------ % File : lazyCoP---0.1 % Problem : MGT028-1 : TPTP v9.3.0. Released v2.4.0. % Transfm : none % Format : tptp:raw % Command : vampire -t 0 --mode clausify %d -updr off -nm 2 -erd input_only -icip on | lazycop % Computer : n003.cluster.edu % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz % Memory : 8046.5625MB % OS : Linux 6.8.0-71-generic % CPULimit : 300s % WCLimit : 300s % DateTime : Tue Sep 8 06:13:17 AM UTC 2026 % Result : Unsatisfiable 2.14s 0.69s % Output : Assurance 0s % Verified : % SZS Type : - % Comments : %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----No solution output by system %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT % 0.00/0.03 % Problem : MGT028-1 : TPTP v9.3.0. Released v2.4.0. % 0.00/0.04 % Command : vampire -t 0 --mode clausify %d -updr off -nm 2 -erd input_only -icip on | lazycop % 0.08/0.36 % Computer : n003.cluster.edu % 0.08/0.36 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % 0.08/0.36 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz % 0.08/0.36 % Memory : 8046.5625MB % 0.08/0.36 % OS : Linux 6.8.0-71-generic % 0.08/0.36 % CPULimit : 300 % 0.08/0.36 % WCLimit : 300 % 0.08/0.36 % DateTime : Mon Sep 7 12:16:39 UTC 2026 % 0.08/0.36 % CPUTime : % 2.14/0.69 % SZS status Unsatisfiable % 2.14/0.69 % SZS output begin IncompleteProof % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c0, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c1, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4), % 2.14/0.69 inference(start, [], [c0])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c2, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X0),appear(efficient_producers,X0)) | greater_or_equal(sk1(X1,X0),X1) | ~in_environment(X0,X1) | ~stable(X0) | ~environment(X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a0, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk4 = X0). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c3, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a0])], [c1, c2])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c4, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X0),appear(efficient_producers,X0)) | greater_or_equal(sk1(X1,X0),X1) | ~in_environment(X0,X1) | ~stable(X0), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a0])], [c1, c2])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c5, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater_or_equal(sk5(X2),X2) | ~greater(X2,appear(efficient_producers,sk4))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a1, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk2(X0) = X2). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a2, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 appear(efficient_producers,X0) = appear(efficient_producers,sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c6, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater_or_equal(sk1(X1,X0),X1) | ~in_environment(X0,X1) | ~stable(X0), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a1, a2])], [c4, c5])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c7, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater_or_equal(sk5(X2),X2), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a1, a2])], [c4, c5])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c8, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X3)) | ~greater_or_equal(X3,sk2(X4)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X4,X3) | ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,sk1(X5,X4))) | ~in_environment(X4,X5) | ~stable(X4) | ~environment(X4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a3, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk5(X2) = X3). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a4, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X2 = sk2(X4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c9, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a3, a4])], [c7, c8])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c10, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X3)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X4,X3) | ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,sk1(X5,X4))) | ~in_environment(X4,X5) | ~stable(X4) | ~environment(X4), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a3, a4])], [c7, c8])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c11, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,sk5(X6))) | ~greater(X6,appear(efficient_producers,sk4))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a5, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 zero = zero). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a6, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 growth_rate(first_movers,X3) = growth_rate(first_movers,sk5(X6))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c12, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X4,X3) | ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,sk1(X5,X4))) | ~in_environment(X4,X5) | ~stable(X4) | ~environment(X4), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a5, a6])], [c10, c11])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c13, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(X6,appear(efficient_producers,sk4)), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a5, a6])], [c10, c11])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c14, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X0),appear(efficient_producers,X0))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a7, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X6 = sk2(X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a8, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 appear(efficient_producers,sk4) = appear(efficient_producers,X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c15, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a7, a8])], [c13, c14])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c16, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,sk4,sk5(X7)) | ~greater(X7,appear(efficient_producers,sk4))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a9, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 first_movers = first_movers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a10, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 efficient_producers = efficient_producers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a11, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X4 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a12, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X3 = sk5(X7)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c17, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,sk1(X5,X4))) | ~in_environment(X4,X5) | ~stable(X4) | ~environment(X4), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a9, a10, a11, a12])], [c12, c16])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c18, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(X7,appear(efficient_producers,sk4)), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a9, a10, a11, a12])], [c12, c16])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c19, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X0),appear(efficient_producers,X0))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a13, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X7 = sk2(X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a14, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 appear(efficient_producers,sk4) = appear(efficient_producers,X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c20, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a13, a14])], [c18, c19])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c21, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X8)) | ~greater_or_equal(X8,sk3(X9)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X9,X8) | ~stable(X9) | ~environment(X9)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a15, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 zero = zero). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a16, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 growth_rate(first_movers,sk1(X5,X4)) = growth_rate(first_movers,X8)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c22, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~in_environment(X4,X5) | ~stable(X4) | ~environment(X4), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a15, a16])], [c17, c21])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c23, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater_or_equal(X8,sk3(X9)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X9,X8) | ~stable(X9) | ~environment(X9), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a15, a16])], [c17, c21])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c24, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X10)) | ~greater_or_equal(X10,sk2(X11)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X11,X10) | greater_or_equal(sk1(X12,X11),X12) | ~in_environment(X11,X12) | ~stable(X11) | ~environment(X11)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a17, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X8 = sk1(X12,X11)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a18, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk3(X9) = X12). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c25, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X9,X8) | ~stable(X9) | ~environment(X9), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a17, a18])], [c23, c24])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c26, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X10)) | ~greater_or_equal(X10,sk2(X11)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X11,X10) | ~in_environment(X11,X12) | ~stable(X11) | ~environment(X11), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a17, a18])], [c23, c24])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c27, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X3))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a19, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 zero = zero). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a20, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 growth_rate(first_movers,X10) = growth_rate(first_movers,X3)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c28, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater_or_equal(X10,sk2(X11)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X11,X10) | ~in_environment(X11,X12) | ~stable(X11) | ~environment(X11), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a19, a20])], [c26, c27])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c29, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater_or_equal(sk5(X2),X2)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a21, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X10 = sk5(X2)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a22, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk2(X11) = X2). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c30, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X11,X10) | ~in_environment(X11,X12) | ~stable(X11) | ~environment(X11), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a21, a22])], [c28, c29])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c31, plain, % 2.14/0.69 subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X4,X3)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a23, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 first_movers = first_movers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a24, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 efficient_producers = efficient_producers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a25, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X11 = X4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a26, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X10 = X3). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c32, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~in_environment(X11,X12) | ~stable(X11) | ~environment(X11), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a23, a24, a25, a26])], [c30, c31])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c33, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 in_environment(X13,sk3(X13)) | ~stable(X13) | ~environment(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a27, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X11 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a28, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X12 = sk3(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c34, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X11) | ~environment(X11), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a27, a28])], [c32, c33])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c35, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X13) | ~environment(X13), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a27, a28])], [c32, c33])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c36, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 stable(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a29, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X13 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c37, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X13), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a29])], [c35, c36])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c38, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a29])], [c35, c36])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c39, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a30, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X13 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c40, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a30])], [c37, c39])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c41, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a31, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X11 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c42, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X11), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a31])], [c34, c41])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c43, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a32, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X11 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c44, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a32])], [c42, c43])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c45, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X14)) | ~greater_or_equal(X14,sk2(X15)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X15,X14) | subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X15,sk1(X16,X15)) | ~in_environment(X15,X16) | ~stable(X15) | ~environment(X15)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a33, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 first_movers = first_movers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a34, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 efficient_producers = efficient_producers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a35, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X9 = X15). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a36, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X8 = sk1(X16,X15)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c46, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X9) | ~environment(X9), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a33, a34, a35, a36])], [c25, c45])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c47, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X14)) | ~greater_or_equal(X14,sk2(X15)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X15,X14) | ~in_environment(X15,X16) | ~stable(X15) | ~environment(X15), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a33, a34, a35, a36])], [c25, c45])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c48, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X3))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a37, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 zero = zero). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a38, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 growth_rate(first_movers,X14) = growth_rate(first_movers,X3)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c49, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater_or_equal(X14,sk2(X15)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X15,X14) | ~in_environment(X15,X16) | ~stable(X15) | ~environment(X15), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a37, a38])], [c47, c48])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c50, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater_or_equal(sk5(X2),X2)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a39, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X14 = sk5(X2)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a40, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk2(X15) = X2). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c51, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X15,X14) | ~in_environment(X15,X16) | ~stable(X15) | ~environment(X15), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a39, a40])], [c49, c50])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c52, plain, % 2.14/0.69 subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X4,X3)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a41, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 first_movers = first_movers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a42, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 efficient_producers = efficient_producers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a43, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X15 = X4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a44, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X14 = X3). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c53, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~in_environment(X15,X16) | ~stable(X15) | ~environment(X15), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a41, a42, a43, a44])], [c51, c52])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c54, plain, % 2.14/0.69 in_environment(X11,X12)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a45, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X15 = X11). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a46, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X16 = X12). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c55, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X15) | ~environment(X15), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a45, a46])], [c53, c54])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c56, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a47, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X15 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c57, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X15), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a47])], [c55, c56])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c58, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a48, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X15 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c59, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a48])], [c57, c58])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c60, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a49, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X9 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c61, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X9), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a49])], [c46, c60])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c62, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a50, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X9 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c63, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a50])], [c61, c62])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c64, plain, % 2.14/0.69 in_environment(X11,X12)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a51, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X4 = X11). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a52, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X5 = X12). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c65, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X4) | ~environment(X4), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a51, a52])], [c22, c64])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c66, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a53, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X4 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c67, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X4), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a53])], [c65, c66])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c68, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a54, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X4 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c69, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a54])], [c67, c68])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c70, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X17)) | ~greater_or_equal(X17,sk3(X18)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X18,X17) | ~stable(X18) | ~environment(X18)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a55, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk1(X1,X0) = X17). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a56, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X1 = sk3(X18)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c71, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~in_environment(X0,X1) | ~stable(X0), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a55, a56])], [c6, c70])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c72, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,X17)) | ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X18,X17) | ~stable(X18) | ~environment(X18), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a55, a56])], [c6, c70])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c73, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X19),appear(efficient_producers,X19)) | ~greater(zero,growth_rate(first_movers,sk1(X20,X19))) | ~in_environment(X19,X20) | ~stable(X19) | ~environment(X19)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a57, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 zero = zero). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a58, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 growth_rate(first_movers,X17) = growth_rate(first_movers,sk1(X20,X19))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c74, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X18,X17) | ~stable(X18) | ~environment(X18), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a57, a58])], [c72, c73])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c75, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X19),appear(efficient_producers,X19)) | ~in_environment(X19,X20) | ~stable(X19) | ~environment(X19), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a57, a58])], [c72, c73])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c76, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(sk2(X0),appear(efficient_producers,X0))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a59, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk2(X19) = sk2(X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a60, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 appear(efficient_producers,X19) = appear(efficient_producers,X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c77, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~in_environment(X19,X20) | ~stable(X19) | ~environment(X19), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a59, a60])], [c75, c76])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c78, plain, % 2.14/0.69 in_environment(X11,X12)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a61, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X19 = X11). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a62, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X20 = X12). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c79, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X19) | ~environment(X19), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a61, a62])], [c77, c78])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c80, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a63, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X19 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c81, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X19), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a63])], [c79, c80])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c82, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a64, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X19 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c83, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a64])], [c81, c82])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c84, axiom, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X21),appear(efficient_producers,X21)) | subpopulations(first_movers,efficient_producers,X21,sk1(X22,X21)) | ~in_environment(X21,X22) | ~stable(X21) | ~environment(X21)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a65, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 first_movers = first_movers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a66, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 efficient_producers = efficient_producers). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a67, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X18 = X21). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a68, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X17 = sk1(X22,X21)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c85, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X18) | ~environment(X18), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a65, a66, a67, a68])], [c74, c84])). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c86, plain, % 2.14/0.69 greater(sk2(X21),appear(efficient_producers,X21)) | ~in_environment(X21,X22) | ~stable(X21) | ~environment(X21), % 2.14/0.69 inference(strict_predicate_extension, [assumptions([a65, a66, a67, a68])], [c74, c84])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c87, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~greater(sk2(X0),appear(efficient_producers,X0))). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a69, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 sk2(X21) = sk2(X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a70, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 appear(efficient_producers,X21) = appear(efficient_producers,X0)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c88, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~in_environment(X21,X22) | ~stable(X21) | ~environment(X21), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a69, a70])], [c86, c87])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c89, plain, % 2.14/0.69 in_environment(X11,X12)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a71, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X21 = X11). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a72, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X22 = X12). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c90, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X21) | ~environment(X21), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a71, a72])], [c88, c89])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c91, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a73, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X21 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c92, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X21), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a73])], [c90, c91])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c93, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a74, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X21 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c94, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a74])], [c92, c93])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c95, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a75, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X18 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c96, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~environment(X18), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a75])], [c85, c95])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c97, plain, % 2.14/0.69 environment(sk4)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a76, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X18 = sk4). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c98, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a76])], [c96, c97])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c99, plain, % 2.14/0.69 in_environment(X11,X12)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a77, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X0 = X11). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a78, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X1 = X12). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c100, plain, % 2.14/0.69 ~stable(X0), % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a77, a78])], [c71, c99])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c101, plain, % 2.14/0.69 stable(X13)). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(a79, assumption, % 2.14/0.69 X0 = X13). % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c102, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(predicate_reduction, [assumptions([a79])], [c100, c101])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 cnf(c103, plain, % 2.14/0.69 $false, % 2.14/0.69 inference(constraint_solving, [ % 2.14/0.69 bind(X0, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X1, sk3(X18)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X2, sk2(X0)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X3, sk5(X2)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X4, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X5, sk3(X9)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X6, sk2(X0)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X7, sk2(X0)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X8, sk1(X5,X4)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X9, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X10, sk5(X2)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X11, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X12, sk3(X9)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X13, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X14, sk5(X2)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X15, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X16, sk3(X9)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X17, sk1(X1,X0)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X18, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X19, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X20, sk3(X18)), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X21, sk4), % 2.14/0.69 bind(X22, sk3(X18)) % 2.14/0.69 ], % 2.14/0.69 [a0, a1, a2, a3, a4, a5, a6, a7, a8, a9, a10, a11, a12, a13, a14, a15, a16, a17, a18, a19, a20, a21, a22, a23, a24, a25, a26, a27, a28, a29, a30, a31, a32, a33, a34, a35, a36, a37, a38, a39, a40, a41, a42, a43, a44, a45, a46, a47, a48, a49, a50, a51, a52, a53, a54, a55, a56, a57, a58, a59, a60, a61, a62, a63, a64, a65, a66, a67, a68, a69, a70, a71, a72, a73, a74, a75, a76, a77, a78, a79])). % 2.14/0.69 % 2.14/0.69 % SZS output end IncompleteProof %------------------------------------------------------------------------------