%------------------------------------------------------------------------------ % File : Beagle---0.9.52 % Problem : NLP234-1 : TPTP v9.0.0. Released v2.4.0. % Transfm : none % Format : tptp:raw % Command : java -Dfile.encoding=UTF-8 -Xms512M -Xmx4G -Xss10M -jar /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/beagle.jar -auto -q -proof -print tff -smtsolver /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/cvc4-1.4-x86_64-linux-opt -liasolver cooper -t %d %s % Computer : n031.cluster.edu % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz % Memory : 8042.1875MB % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 % CPULimit : 300s % WCLimit : 300s % DateTime : Wed Apr 9 07:48:42 PM UTC 2025 % Result : Satisfiable 7.37s 2.63s % Output : Assurance 0s % Verified : % SZS Type : - % Comments : %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----No solution output by system %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT % 0.03/0.13 % Problem : NLP234-1 : TPTP v9.0.0. Released v2.4.0. % 0.03/0.14 % Command : java -Dfile.encoding=UTF-8 -Xms512M -Xmx4G -Xss10M -jar /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/beagle.jar -auto -q -proof -print tff -smtsolver /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/cvc4-1.4-x86_64-linux-opt -liasolver cooper -t %d %s % 0.14/0.35 % Computer : n031.cluster.edu % 0.14/0.35 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % 0.14/0.35 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz % 0.14/0.35 % Memory : 8042.1875MB % 0.14/0.35 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 % 0.14/0.35 % CPULimit : 300 % 0.14/0.35 % WCLimit : 300 % 0.14/0.35 % DateTime : Tue Apr 8 09:38:07 EDT 2025 % 0.14/0.35 % CPUTime : % 7.37/2.63 % 7.37/2.63 % SZS status Satisfiable for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p % 7.37/2.63 % 7.37/2.63 % SZS output start Saturation for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p % 7.37/2.64 %$ be > theme > of > agent > vincent_forename > think_believe_consider > state > smoke > proposition > present > man > jules_forename > forename > event > accessible_world > actual_world > #nlpp > skf7 > skf5 > skf12 > skf10 > ssSkC0 > skc61 > skc60 > skc59 > skc57 > skc56 > skc55 > skc54 > skc53 > skc52 > skc51 > skc50 > skc49 > skc48 > skc47 > skc43 > skc42 > skc41 > skc40 > skc39 > skc38 > skc37 > skc36 > skc35 > skc34 > skc33 > skc32 > skc31 > skc30 > skc29 % 7.37/2.64 % 7.37/2.64 %Foreground sorts: % 7.37/2.64 % 7.37/2.64 % 7.37/2.64 %Background operators: % 7.37/2.64 % 7.37/2.64 % 7.37/2.64 %Foreground operators: % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc51, type, skc51: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(forename, type, forename: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(be, type, be: ($i * $i * $i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc34, type, skc34: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(theme, type, theme: ($i * $i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(present, type, present: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc61, type, skc61: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc59, type, skc59: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc54, type, skc54: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skf12, type, skf12: $i > $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc29, type, skc29: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc39, type, skc39: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc57, type, skc57: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(proposition, type, proposition: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc52, type, skc52: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(of, type, of: ($i * $i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc53, type, skc53: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(actual_world, type, actual_world: $i > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(agent, type, agent: ($i * $i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc36, type, skc36: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skf10, type, skf10: $i > $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc40, type, skc40: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc32, type, skc32: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc41, type, skc41: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc60, type, skc60: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(jules_forename, type, jules_forename: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc43, type, skc43: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc42, type, skc42: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(smoke, type, smoke: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skf5, type, skf5: $i > $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc38, type, skc38: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(event, type, event: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skf7, type, skf7: $i > $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc49, type, skc49: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc56, type, skc56: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(state, type, state: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(think_believe_consider, type, think_believe_consider: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(man, type, man: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc37, type, skc37: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc31, type, skc31: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(vincent_forename, type, vincent_forename: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc48, type, skc48: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc47, type, skc47: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc35, type, skc35: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc50, type, skc50: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc55, type, skc55: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc30, type, skc30: $i). % 7.37/2.64 tff(accessible_world, type, accessible_world: ($i * $i) > $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(ssSkC0, type, ssSkC0: $o). % 7.37/2.64 tff(skc33, type, skc33: $i). % 7.37/2.64 % 7.37/2.64 %Saturated clause set: % 7.37/2.64 tff(c_1792, plain, (![X7_422, X1_419, Y_426, X5_425, X3_428, X6_429, Z_424, X2_423, X4_431]: (~of(skc29, X6_429, X4_431) | ~jules_forename(skc29, X6_429) | ~forename(skc29, X6_429) | ~agent(skc29, X7_422, skc33) | ~theme(skc29, X7_422, Y_426) | ~event(skc29, X7_422) | ~present(skc29, X7_422) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X7_422) | ~event(Y_426, X5_425) | ~agent(Y_426, X5_425, X4_431) | ~present(Y_426, X5_425) | ~smoke(Y_426, X5_425) | ~agent(skc29, X2_423, X4_431) | ~man(skc29, X4_431) | ~of(skc29, X3_428, X4_431) | ~vincent_forename(skc29, X3_428) | ~forename(skc29, X3_428) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X2_423) | ~present(skc29, X2_423) | ~event(skc29, X2_423) | ~theme(skc29, X2_423, Z_424) | ~proposition(skc29, Z_424) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Z_424) | ~event(Z_424, X1_419) | ~agent(Z_424, X1_419, skf7(Z_424)) | ~present(Z_424, X1_419) | ~smoke(Z_424, X1_419) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Y_426) | ~proposition(skc29, Y_426)))). % 7.37/2.64 tff(c_1740, plain, (![X7_422, X1_419, Y_426, X5_425, X3_428, X6_429, Z_424, X2_423, X4_431]: (~of(skc29, X6_429, X4_431) | ~jules_forename(skc29, X6_429) | ~forename(skc29, X6_429) | ~agent(skc29, X7_422, skc43) | ~theme(skc29, X7_422, Y_426) | ~event(skc29, X7_422) | ~present(skc29, X7_422) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X7_422) | ~event(Y_426, X5_425) | ~agent(Y_426, X5_425, X4_431) | ~present(Y_426, X5_425) | ~smoke(Y_426, X5_425) | ~agent(skc29, X2_423, X4_431) | ~man(skc29, X4_431) | ~of(skc29, X3_428, X4_431) | ~vincent_forename(skc29, X3_428) | ~forename(skc29, X3_428) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X2_423) | ~present(skc29, X2_423) | ~event(skc29, X2_423) | ~theme(skc29, X2_423, Z_424) | ~proposition(skc29, Z_424) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Z_424) | ~event(Z_424, X1_419) | ~agent(Z_424, X1_419, skf7(Z_424)) | ~present(Z_424, X1_419) | ~smoke(Z_424, X1_419) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Y_426) | ~proposition(skc29, Y_426)))). % 7.37/2.64 tff(c_1709, plain, (~vincent_forename(skc29, skc39))). % 7.37/2.64 tff(c_1707, plain, (![X4_451]: (~event(skc40, X4_451) | ~agent(skc40, X4_451, skc38) | ~present(skc40, X4_451) | ~smoke(skc40, X4_451)))). % 7.37/2.64 tff(c_1696, plain, (![X6_446, Y_444, X4_447]: (~agent(skc29, X6_446, skc43) | ~theme(skc29, X6_446, Y_444) | ~event(skc29, X6_446) | ~present(skc29, X6_446) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X6_446) | ~event(Y_444, X4_447) | ~agent(Y_444, X4_447, skc38) | ~present(Y_444, X4_447) | ~smoke(Y_444, X4_447) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Y_444) | ~proposition(skc29, Y_444)))). % 7.37/2.64 tff(c_1674, plain, (![X1_390, X4_400, X6_397, X2_394, X5_398, X3_395, Z_393, Y_396]: (man(Z_393, skf7(Z_393)) | ~of(skc29, X5_398, X3_395) | ~jules_forename(skc29, X5_398) | ~forename(skc29, X5_398) | ~agent(skc29, X6_397, skc43) | ~theme(skc29, X6_397, Y_396) | ~event(skc29, X6_397) | ~present(skc29, X6_397) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X6_397) | ~event(Y_396, X4_400) | ~agent(Y_396, X4_400, X3_395) | ~present(Y_396, X4_400) | ~smoke(Y_396, X4_400) | ~agent(skc29, X1_390, X3_395) | ~man(skc29, X3_395) | ~of(skc29, X2_394, X3_395) | ~vincent_forename(skc29, X2_394) | ~forename(skc29, X2_394) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X1_390) | ~present(skc29, X1_390) | ~event(skc29, X1_390) | ~theme(skc29, X1_390, Z_393) | ~proposition(skc29, Z_393) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Z_393) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Y_396) | ~proposition(skc29, Y_396)))). % 7.37/2.64 tff(c_1643, plain, (~jules_forename(skc29, skc42))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1642, plain, (~jules_forename(skc29, skc32))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1641, plain, (~vincent_forename(skc29, skc34))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1633, plain, (![X2_407]: (~of(skc29, X2_407, skc35) | ~vincent_forename(skc29, X2_407) | ~forename(skc29, X2_407)))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1588, plain, (~agent(skc29, skc41, skc33))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1590, plain, (![X4_58, X1_52, V_56, X8_57, W_46, X_54, X5_44, X6_45, X3_47, X2_53, Y_55, U_48, Z_50, X9_49, X7_51]: (~actual_world(U_48) | ~of(U_48, X8_57, X9_49) | ~man(U_48, X9_49) | ~agent(U_48, X7_51, X9_49) | ~forename(U_48, X8_57) | ~vincent_forename(U_48, X8_57) | ~theme(U_48, X7_51, Y_55) | ~event(U_48, X7_51) | ~present(U_48, X7_51) | ~think_believe_consider(U_48, X7_51) | ~of(U_48, X6_45, X4_58) | ~jules_forename(U_48, X6_45) | ~forename(U_48, X6_45) | ~event(Y_55, X5_44) | ~agent(Y_55, X5_44, X4_58) | ~present(Y_55, X5_44) | ~smoke(Y_55, X5_44) | ~agent(U_48, X2_53, X4_58) | ~man(U_48, X4_58) | ~of(U_48, X3_47, X4_58) | ~vincent_forename(U_48, X3_47) | ~forename(U_48, X3_47) | ~think_believe_consider(U_48, X2_53) | ~present(U_48, X2_53) | ~event(U_48, X2_53) | ~theme(U_48, X2_53, Z_50) | ~proposition(U_48, Z_50) | ~accessible_world(U_48, Z_50) | ~event(Z_50, X1_52) | ~agent(Z_50, X1_52, skf7(Z_50)) | ~present(Z_50, X1_52) | ~smoke(Z_50, X1_52) | ~accessible_world(U_48, Y_55) | ~proposition(U_48, Y_55) | ~forename(U_48, X_54) | ~jules_forename(U_48, X_54) | ~of(U_48, X_54, W_46) | ~man(U_48, W_46) | ~be(U_48, V_56, W_46, W_46) | ~state(U_48, V_56)))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1583, plain, (![X4_415]: (~event(skc30, X4_415) | ~agent(skc30, X4_415, skc38) | ~present(skc30, X4_415) | ~smoke(skc30, X4_415)))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1574, plain, (![X6_410, Y_408, X4_411]: (~agent(skc29, X6_410, skc33) | ~theme(skc29, X6_410, Y_408) | ~event(skc29, X6_410) | ~present(skc29, X6_410) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X6_410) | ~event(Y_408, X4_411) | ~agent(Y_408, X4_411, skc38) | ~present(Y_408, X4_411) | ~smoke(Y_408, X4_411) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Y_408) | ~proposition(skc29, Y_408)))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1552, plain, (![X1_390, X4_400, X6_397, X2_394, X5_398, X3_395, Z_393, Y_396]: (man(Z_393, skf7(Z_393)) | ~of(skc29, X5_398, X3_395) | ~jules_forename(skc29, X5_398) | ~forename(skc29, X5_398) | ~agent(skc29, X6_397, skc33) | ~theme(skc29, X6_397, Y_396) | ~event(skc29, X6_397) | ~present(skc29, X6_397) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X6_397) | ~event(Y_396, X4_400) | ~agent(Y_396, X4_400, X3_395) | ~present(Y_396, X4_400) | ~smoke(Y_396, X4_400) | ~agent(skc29, X1_390, X3_395) | ~man(skc29, X3_395) | ~of(skc29, X2_394, X3_395) | ~vincent_forename(skc29, X2_394) | ~forename(skc29, X2_394) | ~think_believe_consider(skc29, X1_390) | ~present(skc29, X1_390) | ~event(skc29, X1_390) | ~theme(skc29, X1_390, Z_393) | ~proposition(skc29, Z_393) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Z_393) | ~accessible_world(skc29, Y_396) | ~proposition(skc29, Y_396)))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1500, plain, (![Y_25, X3_18, U_19, X7_21, X8_27, Z_20, W_17, V_26, X4_28, X2_23, X1_22, X6_16, X5_15, X_24]: (man(Z_20, skf7(Z_20)) | ~actual_world(U_19) | ~of(U_19, X7_21, X8_27) | ~man(U_19, X8_27) | ~agent(U_19, X6_16, X8_27) | ~forename(U_19, X7_21) | ~vincent_forename(U_19, X7_21) | ~theme(U_19, X6_16, Y_25) | ~event(U_19, X6_16) | ~present(U_19, X6_16) | ~think_believe_consider(U_19, X6_16) | ~of(U_19, X5_15, X3_18) | ~jules_forename(U_19, X5_15) | ~forename(U_19, X5_15) | ~event(Y_25, X4_28) | ~agent(Y_25, X4_28, X3_18) | ~present(Y_25, X4_28) | ~smoke(Y_25, X4_28) | ~agent(U_19, X1_22, X3_18) | ~man(U_19, X3_18) | ~of(U_19, X2_23, X3_18) | ~vincent_forename(U_19, X2_23) | ~forename(U_19, X2_23) | ~think_believe_consider(U_19, X1_22) | ~present(U_19, X1_22) | ~event(U_19, X1_22) | ~theme(U_19, X1_22, Z_20) | ~proposition(U_19, Z_20) | ~accessible_world(U_19, Z_20) | ~accessible_world(U_19, Y_25) | ~proposition(U_19, Y_25) | ~forename(U_19, X_24) | ~jules_forename(U_19, X_24) | ~of(U_19, X_24, W_17) | ~man(U_19, W_17) | ~be(U_19, V_26, W_17, W_17) | ~state(U_19, V_26)))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1487, plain, (![U_9]: (~man(skc40, U_9)))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1484, plain, (be(skc29, skc37, skc38, skc38))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1479, plain, (agent(skc30, skc36, skc35))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1476, plain, (of(skc29, skc32, skc33))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1473, plain, (of(skc29, skc42, skc43))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1470, plain, (agent(skc29, skc31, skc33))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1468, plain, (agent(skc29, skc41, skc43))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1466, plain, (theme(skc29, skc31, skc30))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1462, plain, (theme(skc29, skc41, skc40))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1459, plain, (of(skc29, skc39, skc38))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1456, plain, (of(skc29, skc34, skc35))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1454, plain, (event(skc30, skc36))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1452, plain, (jules_forename(skc29, skc39))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1449, plain, (accessible_world(skc29, skc30))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1447, plain, (forename(skc29, skc34))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1445, plain, (jules_forename(skc29, skc34))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1443, plain, (proposition(skc29, skc30))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1441, plain, (forename(skc29, skc39))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1439, plain, (man(skc29, skc38))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1437, plain, (think_believe_consider(skc29, skc31))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1433, plain, (present(skc29, skc31))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1430, plain, (state(skc29, skc37))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1428, plain, (man(skc29, skc43))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1426, plain, (forename(skc29, skc42))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1424, plain, (present(skc30, skc36))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1421, plain, (vincent_forename(skc29, skc42))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1418, plain, (present(skc29, skc41))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1416, plain, (man(skc29, skc33))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1413, plain, (event(skc29, skc41))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1410, plain, (event(skc29, skc31))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1407, plain, (think_believe_consider(skc29, skc41))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1401, plain, (accessible_world(skc29, skc40))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1399, plain, (vincent_forename(skc29, skc32))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1393, plain, (man(skc29, skc35))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1390, plain, (forename(skc29, skc32))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1388, plain, (proposition(skc29, skc40))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1378, plain, (smoke(skc30, skc36))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_1379, plain, (ssSkC0)). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_2, plain, (actual_world(skc47))). % 7.37/2.65 tff(c_4, plain, (actual_world(skc29))). % 7.37/2.65 % SZS output end Saturation for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p % 7.37/2.65 %------------------------------------------------------------------------------