%------------------------------------------------------------------------------ % File : Otter---3.3 % Problem : NLP254+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0. % Transfm : none % Format : tptp:raw % Command : otter-tptp-script %s % Computer : n010.cluster.edu % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz % Memory : 8042.1875MB % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 % CPULimit : 300s % WCLimit : 300s % DateTime : Wed Jul 27 13:07:21 EDT 2022 % Result : Unknown 3.77s 3.96s % Output : None % Verified : % SZS Type : - % Comments : %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----No solution output by system %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT % 0.00/0.11 % Problem : NLP254+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0. % 0.00/0.12 % Command : otter-tptp-script %s % 0.12/0.32 % Computer : n010.cluster.edu % 0.12/0.32 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % 0.12/0.32 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz % 0.12/0.32 % Memory : 8042.1875MB % 0.12/0.32 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 % 0.12/0.32 % CPULimit : 300 % 0.12/0.32 % WCLimit : 300 % 0.12/0.33 % DateTime : Wed Jul 27 08:38:09 EDT 2022 % 0.12/0.33 % CPUTime : % 1.98/2.19 ----- Otter 3.3f, August 2004 ----- % 1.98/2.19 The process was started by sandbox on n010.cluster.edu, % 1.98/2.19 Wed Jul 27 08:38:09 2022 % 1.98/2.19 The command was "./otter". The process ID is 2045. % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 set(prolog_style_variables). % 1.98/2.19 set(auto). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(auto1). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(process_input). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: clear(print_kept). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: clear(print_new_demod). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: clear(print_back_demod). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: clear(print_back_sub). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(control_memory). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: assign(max_mem, 12000). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: assign(pick_given_ratio, 4). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: assign(stats_level, 1). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: assign(max_seconds, 10800). % 1.98/2.19 clear(print_given). % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 formula_list(usable). % 1.98/2.19 all A (A=A). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (jules_forename(U,V)->forename(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (vincent_forename(U,V)->forename(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (relname(U,V)->relation(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (forename(U,V)->relname(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (man(U,V)->male(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (human_person(U,V)->animate(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (human_person(U,V)->human(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (organism(U,V)->living(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (organism(U,V)->impartial(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (entity(U,V)->existent(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (entity(U,V)->specific(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (entity(U,V)->thing(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (organism(U,V)->entity(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (human_person(U,V)->organism(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (man(U,V)->human_person(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (state(U,V)->event(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (state(U,V)->eventuality(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (abstraction(U,V)->unisex(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (abstraction(U,V)->general(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (abstraction(U,V)->nonhuman(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (abstraction(U,V)->thing(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (relation(U,V)->abstraction(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (proposition(U,V)->relation(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (eventuality(U,V)->unisex(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (eventuality(U,V)->nonexistent(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (eventuality(U,V)->specific(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (thing(U,V)->singleton(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (eventuality(U,V)->thing(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (event(U,V)->eventuality(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (smoke(U,V)->event(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (existent(U,V)-> -nonexistent(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (nonhuman(U,V)-> -human(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (specific(U,V)-> -general(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V (unisex(U,V)-> -male(U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&jules_forename(V,U)->jules_forename(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W X (accessible_world(W,X)&of(W,U,V)->of(X,U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&vincent_forename(V,U)->vincent_forename(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&relname(V,U)->relname(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&forename(V,U)->forename(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&male(V,U)->male(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&animate(V,U)->animate(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&human(V,U)->human(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&living(V,U)->living(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&impartial(V,U)->impartial(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&existent(V,U)->existent(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&entity(V,U)->entity(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&organism(V,U)->organism(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&human_person(V,U)->human_person(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&man(V,U)->man(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&state(V,U)->state(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W X Y (accessible_world(X,Y)&be(X,U,V,W)->be(Y,U,V,W)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&general(V,U)->general(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&nonhuman(V,U)->nonhuman(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&abstraction(V,U)->abstraction(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&relation(V,U)->relation(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&proposition(V,U)->proposition(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W X (accessible_world(W,X)&theme(W,U,V)->theme(X,U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&think_believe_consider(V,U)->think_believe_consider(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W X (accessible_world(W,X)&agent(W,U,V)->agent(X,U,V)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&present(V,U)->present(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&unisex(V,U)->unisex(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&nonexistent(V,U)->nonexistent(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&specific(V,U)->specific(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&singleton(V,U)->singleton(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&thing(V,U)->thing(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&eventuality(V,U)->eventuality(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&event(V,U)->event(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (accessible_world(V,W)&smoke(V,U)->smoke(W,U)). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W (entity(U,V)&forename(U,W)&of(U,W,V)-> -(exists X (forename(U,X)&X!=W&of(U,X,V)))). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W X (be(U,V,W,X)->W=X). % 1.98/2.19 all U V W X Y Z (think_believe_consider(U,V)&proposition(U,Y)&theme(U,V,Y)&agent(U,V,X)&think_believe_consider(U,W)&proposition(U,Z)&theme(U,W,Z)&agent(U,W,X)->Y=Z). % 1.98/2.19 -(-((exists U (actual_world(U)& (exists V W X Y Z X1 X2 (of(U,W,V)&man(U,V)&vincent_forename(U,W)&forename(U,W)&proposition(U,Y)&agent(U,X,V)&theme(U,X,Y)&event(U,X)&present(U,X)&think_believe_consider(U,X)&accessible_world(U,Y)& (all X3 (man(Y,X3)-> (exists X4 (event(Y,X4)&agent(Y,X4,X3)&present(Y,X4)&smoke(Y,X4)))))&of(U,Z,X1)&man(U,X1)&jules_forename(U,Z)&forename(U,Z)&man(U,X1)&state(U,X2)&be(U,X2,X1,X1)))))& -(exists X5 (actual_world(X5)& (exists X6 X7 X8 V W X Y Z X1 X2 X9 X10 (of(X5,X7,X6)&man(X5,X6)&jules_forename(X5,X7)&forename(X5,X7)&of(X5,X8,X1)&vincent_forename(X5,X8)&forename(X5,X8)&of(X5,W,V)&man(X5,V)&vincent_forename(X5,W)&forename(X5,W)&proposition(X5,Y)&agent(X5,X,V)&theme(X5,X,Y)&event(X5,X)&present(X5,X)&think_believe_consider(X5,X)&accessible_world(X5,Y)& (all X3 (man(Y,X3)-> (exists X4 (event(Y,X4)&agent(Y,X4,X3)&present(Y,X4)&smoke(Y,X4)))))&of(X5,Z,X1)&man(X5,X1)&jules_forename(X5,Z)&forename(X5,Z)&man(X5,X1)&state(X5,X2)&be(X5,X2,X1,X1)&proposition(X5,X10)&agent(X5,X9,X1)&theme(X5,X9,X10)&event(X5,X9)&present(X5,X9)&think_believe_consider(X5,X9)&accessible_world(X5,X10)& (exists X11 (event(X10,X11)&agent(X10,X11,X6)&present(X10,X11)&smoke(X10,X11))))))))). % 1.98/2.19 end_of_list. % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 -------> usable clausifies to: % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 list(usable). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] A=A. % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -jules_forename(U,V)|forename(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -vincent_forename(U,V)|forename(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -relname(U,V)|relation(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -forename(U,V)|relname(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -man(U,V)|male(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -human_person(U,V)|animate(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -human_person(U,V)|human(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -organism(U,V)|living(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -organism(U,V)|impartial(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -entity(U,V)|existent(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -entity(U,V)|specific(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -entity(U,V)|thing(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -organism(U,V)|entity(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -human_person(U,V)|organism(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -man(U,V)|human_person(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -state(U,V)|event(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -state(U,V)|eventuality(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -abstraction(U,V)|unisex(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -abstraction(U,V)|general(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -abstraction(U,V)|nonhuman(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -abstraction(U,V)|thing(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -relation(U,V)|abstraction(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -proposition(U,V)|relation(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -eventuality(U,V)|unisex(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -eventuality(U,V)|nonexistent(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -eventuality(U,V)|specific(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -thing(U,V)|singleton(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -eventuality(U,V)|thing(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -event(U,V)|eventuality(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -smoke(U,V)|event(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -existent(U,V)| -nonexistent(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -nonhuman(U,V)| -human(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -specific(U,V)| -general(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -unisex(U,V)| -male(U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -jules_forename(V,U)|jules_forename(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(W,X)| -of(W,U,V)|of(X,U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -vincent_forename(V,U)|vincent_forename(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -relname(V,U)|relname(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -forename(V,U)|forename(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -male(V,U)|male(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -animate(V,U)|animate(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -human(V,U)|human(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -living(V,U)|living(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -impartial(V,U)|impartial(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -existent(V,U)|existent(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -entity(V,U)|entity(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -organism(V,U)|organism(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -human_person(V,U)|human_person(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -man(V,U)|man(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -state(V,U)|state(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(X,Y)| -be(X,U,V,W)|be(Y,U,V,W). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -general(V,U)|general(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -nonhuman(V,U)|nonhuman(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -abstraction(V,U)|abstraction(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -relation(V,U)|relation(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -proposition(V,U)|proposition(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(W,X)| -theme(W,U,V)|theme(X,U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -think_believe_consider(V,U)|think_believe_consider(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(W,X)| -agent(W,U,V)|agent(X,U,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -present(V,U)|present(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -unisex(V,U)|unisex(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -nonexistent(V,U)|nonexistent(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -specific(V,U)|specific(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -singleton(V,U)|singleton(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -thing(V,U)|thing(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -eventuality(V,U)|eventuality(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -event(V,U)|event(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -accessible_world(V,W)| -smoke(V,U)|smoke(W,U). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -entity(U,V)| -forename(U,W)| -of(U,W,V)| -forename(U,X)|X=W| -of(U,X,V). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -be(U,V,W,X)|W=X. % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -think_believe_consider(U,V)| -proposition(U,Y)| -theme(U,V,Y)| -agent(U,V,X)| -think_believe_consider(U,W)| -proposition(U,Z)| -theme(U,W,Z)| -agent(U,W,X)|Y=Z. % 1.98/2.19 0 [] actual_world($c8). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] of($c8,$c6,$c7). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] man($c8,$c7). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] vincent_forename($c8,$c6). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] forename($c8,$c6). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] proposition($c8,$c4). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] agent($c8,$c5,$c7). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] theme($c8,$c5,$c4). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] event($c8,$c5). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] present($c8,$c5). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] think_believe_consider($c8,$c5). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] accessible_world($c8,$c4). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -man($c4,X3)|event($c4,$f1(X3)). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -man($c4,X3)|agent($c4,$f1(X3),X3). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -man($c4,X3)|present($c4,$f1(X3)). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -man($c4,X3)|smoke($c4,$f1(X3)). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] of($c8,$c3,$c2). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] man($c8,$c2). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] jules_forename($c8,$c3). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] forename($c8,$c3). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] state($c8,$c1). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] be($c8,$c1,$c2,$c2). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -actual_world(X5)| -of(X5,X7,X6)| -man(X5,X6)| -jules_forename(X5,X7)| -forename(X5,X7)| -of(X5,X8,X1)| -vincent_forename(X5,X8)| -forename(X5,X8)| -of(X5,W,V)| -man(X5,V)| -vincent_forename(X5,W)| -forename(X5,W)| -proposition(X5,Y)| -agent(X5,X,V)| -theme(X5,X,Y)| -event(X5,X)| -present(X5,X)| -think_believe_consider(X5,X)| -accessible_world(X5,Y)|man(Y,$f2(X5,X6,X7,X8,V,W,X,Y,Z,X1,X2,X9,X10))| -of(X5,Z,X1)| -man(X5,X1)| -jules_forename(X5,Z)| -forename(X5,Z)| -state(X5,X2)| -be(X5,X2,X1,X1)| -proposition(X5,X10)| -agent(X5,X9,X1)| -theme(X5,X9,X10)| -event(X5,X9)| -present(X5,X9)| -think_believe_consider(X5,X9)| -accessible_world(X5,X10)| -event(X10,X11)| -agent(X10,X11,X6)| -present(X10,X11)| -smoke(X10,X11). % 1.98/2.19 0 [] -actual_world(X5)| -of(X5,X7,X6)| -man(X5,X6)| -jules_forename(X5,X7)| -forename(X5,X7)| -of(X5,X8,X1)| -vincent_forename(X5,X8)| -forename(X5,X8)| -of(X5,W,V)| -man(X5,V)| -vincent_forename(X5,W)| -forename(X5,W)| -proposition(X5,Y)| -agent(X5,X,V)| -theme(X5,X,Y)| -event(X5,X)| -present(X5,X)| -think_believe_consider(X5,X)| -accessible_world(X5,Y)| -event(Y,X4)| -agent(Y,X4,$f2(X5,X6,X7,X8,V,W,X,Y,Z,X1,X2,X9,X10))| -present(Y,X4)| -smoke(Y,X4)| -of(X5,Z,X1)| -man(X5,X1)| -jules_forename(X5,Z)| -forename(X5,Z)| -state(X5,X2)| -be(X5,X2,X1,X1)| -proposition(X5,X10)| -agent(X5,X9,X1)| -theme(X5,X9,X10)| -event(X5,X9)| -present(X5,X9)| -think_believe_consider(X5,X9)| -accessible_world(X5,X10)| -event(X10,X11)| -agent(X10,X11,X6)| -present(X10,X11)| -smoke(X10,X11). % 1.98/2.19 end_of_list. % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 SCAN INPUT: prop=0, horn=1, equality=1, symmetry=0, max_lits=40. % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 This is a Horn set with equality. The strategy will be % 1.98/2.19 Knuth-Bendix and hyper_res, with positive clauses in % 1.98/2.19 sos and nonpositive clauses in usable. % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(knuth_bendix). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(anl_eq). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(para_from). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(para_into). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: clear(para_from_right). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: clear(para_into_right). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(para_from_vars). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(eq_units_both_ways). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(dynamic_demod_all). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(dynamic_demod). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(order_eq). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(back_demod). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(lrpo). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: set(hyper_res). % 1.98/2.19 dependent: clear(order_hyper). % 1.98/2.19 % 1.98/2.19 ------------> process usable: % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 1 [] -jules_forename(A,B)|forename(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 2 [] -vincent_forename(A,B)|forename(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 3 [] -relname(A,B)|relation(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 4 [] -forename(A,B)|relname(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 5 [] -man(A,B)|male(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 6 [] -human_person(A,B)|animate(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 7 [] -human_person(A,B)|human(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 8 [] -organism(A,B)|living(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 9 [] -organism(A,B)|impartial(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 10 [] -entity(A,B)|existent(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 11 [] -entity(A,B)|specific(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 12 [] -entity(A,B)|thing(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 13 [] -organism(A,B)|entity(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 14 [] -human_person(A,B)|organism(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 15 [] -man(A,B)|human_person(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 16 [] -state(A,B)|event(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 17 [] -state(A,B)|eventuality(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 18 [] -abstraction(A,B)|unisex(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 19 [] -abstraction(A,B)|general(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 20 [] -abstraction(A,B)|nonhuman(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 21 [] -abstraction(A,B)|thing(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 22 [] -relation(A,B)|abstraction(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 23 [] -proposition(A,B)|relation(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 24 [] -eventuality(A,B)|unisex(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 25 [] -eventuality(A,B)|nonexistent(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 26 [] -eventuality(A,B)|specific(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 27 [] -thing(A,B)|singleton(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 28 [] -eventuality(A,B)|thing(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 29 [] -event(A,B)|eventuality(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 30 [] -smoke(A,B)|event(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 31 [] -existent(A,B)| -nonexistent(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 32 [] -nonhuman(A,B)| -human(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 33 [] -specific(A,B)| -general(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=6): 34 [] -unisex(A,B)| -male(A,B). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 35 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -jules_forename(A,C)|jules_forename(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=11): 36 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -of(A,C,D)|of(B,C,D). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 37 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -vincent_forename(A,C)|vincent_forename(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 38 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -relname(A,C)|relname(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 39 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -forename(A,C)|forename(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 40 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -male(A,C)|male(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 41 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -animate(A,C)|animate(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 42 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -human(A,C)|human(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 43 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -living(A,C)|living(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 44 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -impartial(A,C)|impartial(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 45 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -existent(A,C)|existent(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 46 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -entity(A,C)|entity(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 47 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -organism(A,C)|organism(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 48 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -human_person(A,C)|human_person(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 49 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -man(A,C)|man(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 50 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -state(A,C)|state(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=13): 51 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -be(A,C,D,E)|be(B,C,D,E). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 52 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -general(A,C)|general(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 53 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -nonhuman(A,C)|nonhuman(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 54 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -abstraction(A,C)|abstraction(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 55 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -relation(A,C)|relation(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 56 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -proposition(A,C)|proposition(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=11): 57 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -theme(A,C,D)|theme(B,C,D). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 58 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -think_believe_consider(A,C)|think_believe_consider(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=11): 59 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -agent(A,C,D)|agent(B,C,D). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 60 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -present(A,C)|present(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 61 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -unisex(A,C)|unisex(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 62 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -nonexistent(A,C)|nonexistent(B,C). % 1.98/2.19 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 63 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -specific(A,C)|specific(B,C). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 64 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -singleton(A,C)|singleton(B,C). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 65 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -thing(A,C)|thing(B,C). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 66 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -eventuality(A,C)|eventuality(B,C). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 67 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -event(A,C)|event(B,C). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=9): 68 [] -accessible_world(A,B)| -smoke(A,C)|smoke(B,C). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=20): 69 [] -entity(A,B)| -forename(A,C)| -of(A,C,B)| -forename(A,D)|D=C| -of(A,D,B). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=8): 70 [] -be(A,B,C,D)|C=D. % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=31): 71 [] -think_believe_consider(A,B)| -proposition(A,C)| -theme(A,B,C)| -agent(A,B,D)| -think_believe_consider(A,E)| -proposition(A,F)| -theme(A,E,F)| -agent(A,E,D)|C=F. % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=7): 72 [] -man($c4,A)|event($c4,$f1(A)). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=8): 73 [] -man($c4,A)|agent($c4,$f1(A),A). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=7): 74 [] -man($c4,A)|present($c4,$f1(A)). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=7): 75 [] -man($c4,A)|smoke($c4,$f1(A)). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=134): 76 [] -actual_world(A)| -of(A,B,C)| -man(A,C)| -jules_forename(A,B)| -forename(A,B)| -of(A,D,E)| -vincent_forename(A,D)| -forename(A,D)| -of(A,F,G)| -man(A,G)| -vincent_forename(A,F)| -forename(A,F)| -proposition(A,H)| -agent(A,I,G)| -theme(A,I,H)| -event(A,I)| -present(A,I)| -think_believe_consider(A,I)| -accessible_world(A,H)|man(H,$f2(A,C,B,D,G,F,I,H,J,E,K,L,M))| -of(A,J,E)| -man(A,E)| -jules_forename(A,J)| -forename(A,J)| -state(A,K)| -be(A,K,E,E)| -proposition(A,M)| -agent(A,L,E)| -theme(A,L,M)| -event(A,L)| -present(A,L)| -think_believe_consider(A,L)| -accessible_world(A,M)| -event(M,N)| -agent(M,N,C)| -present(M,N)| -smoke(M,N). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=144): 77 [] -actual_world(A)| -of(A,B,C)| -man(A,C)| -jules_forename(A,B)| -forename(A,B)| -of(A,D,E)| -vincent_forename(A,D)| -forename(A,D)| -of(A,F,G)| -man(A,G)| -vincent_forename(A,F)| -forename(A,F)| -proposition(A,H)| -agent(A,I,G)| -theme(A,I,H)| -event(A,I)| -present(A,I)| -think_believe_consider(A,I)| -accessible_world(A,H)| -event(H,J)| -agent(H,J,$f2(A,C,B,D,G,F,I,H,K,E,L,M,N))| -present(H,J)| -smoke(H,J)| -of(A,K,E)| -man(A,E)| -jules_forename(A,K)| -forename(A,K)| -state(A,L)| -be(A,L,E,E)| -proposition(A,N)| -agent(A,M,E)| -theme(A,M,N)| -event(A,M)| -present(A,M)| -think_believe_consider(A,M)| -accessible_world(A,N)| -event(N,O)| -agent(N,O,C)| -present(N,O)| -smoke(N,O). % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 ------------> process sos: % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 78 [] A=A. % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=2): 79 [] actual_world($c8). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=4): 80 [] of($c8,$c6,$c7). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 81 [] man($c8,$c7). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 82 [] vincent_forename($c8,$c6). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 83 [] forename($c8,$c6). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 84 [] proposition($c8,$c4). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=4): 85 [] agent($c8,$c5,$c7). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=4): 86 [] theme($c8,$c5,$c4). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 87 [] event($c8,$c5). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 88 [] present($c8,$c5). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 89 [] think_believe_consider($c8,$c5). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 90 [] accessible_world($c8,$c4). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=4): 91 [] of($c8,$c3,$c2). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 92 [] man($c8,$c2). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 93 [] jules_forename($c8,$c3). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 94 [] forename($c8,$c3). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=3): 95 [] state($c8,$c1). % 3.77/3.96 ** KEPT (pick-wt=5): 96 [] be($c8,$c1,$c2,$c2). % 3.77/3.96 Following clause subsumed by 78 during input processing: 0 [copy,78,flip.1] A=A. % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 ======= end of input processing ======= % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 =========== start of search =========== % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 Resetting weight limit to 8. % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 Resetting weight limit to 8. % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 sos_size=2114 % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 Search stopped because sos empty. % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 Search stopped because sos empty. % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 ============ end of search ============ % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 -------------- statistics ------------- % 3.77/3.96 clauses given 2483 % 3.77/3.96 clauses generated 23174 % 3.77/3.96 clauses kept 2560 % 3.77/3.96 clauses forward subsumed 767 % 3.77/3.96 clauses back subsumed 53 % 3.77/3.96 Kbytes malloced 4882 % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 ----------- times (seconds) ----------- % 3.77/3.96 user CPU time 1.78 (0 hr, 0 min, 1 sec) % 3.77/3.96 system CPU time 0.00 (0 hr, 0 min, 0 sec) % 3.77/3.96 wall-clock time 4 (0 hr, 0 min, 4 sec) % 3.77/3.96 % 3.77/3.96 Process 2045 finished Wed Jul 27 08:38:13 2022 % 3.77/3.96 Otter interrupted % 3.77/3.96 PROOF NOT FOUND %------------------------------------------------------------------------------