%------------------------------------------------------------------------------ % File : Refute---2015 % Problem : NLP256+1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0. % Transfm : none % Format : tptp:raw % Command : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s % Computer : n023.star.cs.uiowa.edu % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 2.40GHz % Memory : 16091.75MB % OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64 % CPULimit : 300s % DateTime : Thu Apr 14 01:28:39 EDT 2016 % Result : Timeout 300.31s % Output : None % Verified : % SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails) % Syntax : Number of formulae : 0 % Comments : %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----No solution output by system %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT % 0.00/0.03 % Problem : NLP256+1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0. % 0.03/0.04 % Command : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s % 0.03/0.23 % Computer : n023.star.cs.uiowa.edu % 0.03/0.23 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % 0.03/0.23 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 @ 2.40GHz % 0.03/0.23 % Memory : 16091.75MB % 0.03/0.23 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64 % 0.03/0.23 % CPULimit : 300 % 0.03/0.23 % DateTime : Tue Apr 5 14:41:39 CDT 2016 % 0.03/0.23 % CPUTime : % 6.26/6.26 > val it = (): unit % 6.58/6.54 Trying to find a model that refutes: ~ ((EX U. bnd_actual_world U & % 6.58/6.54 (EX V W X Y Z X1 X2. % 6.58/6.54 (((((((((((((((((bnd_of U W V & bnd_man U V) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_vincent_forename U W) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_forename U W) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_proposition U Y) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_agent U X V) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_theme U X Y) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_event U X) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_present U X) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_think_believe_consider U X) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_accessible_world U Y) & % 6.58/6.54 (ALL X3. % 6.58/6.54 bnd_man Y X3 --> % 6.58/6.54 (EX X4. % 6.58/6.54 ((bnd_event Y X4 & bnd_agent Y X4 X3) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_present Y X4) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_smoke Y X4))) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_of U Z X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_man U X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_jules_forename U Z) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_forename U Z) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_man U X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_state U X2) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_be U X2 X1 X1)) & % 6.58/6.54 ~ (EX X5. % 6.58/6.54 bnd_actual_world X5 & % 6.58/6.54 (EX X6 X7 V W X Y Z X1 X2 X8 X9. % 6.58/6.54 (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((bnd_of X5 X6 V & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_jules_forename X5 X6) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_forename X5 X6) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_of X5 X7 X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_vincent_forename X5 X7) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_forename X5 X7) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_of X5 W V) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_man X5 V) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_vincent_forename X5 W) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_forename X5 W) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_proposition X5 Y) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_agent X5 X V) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_theme X5 X Y) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_event X5 X) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_present X5 X) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_think_believe_consider X5 X) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_accessible_world X5 Y) & % 6.58/6.54 (ALL X3. % 6.58/6.54 bnd_man Y X3 --> % 6.58/6.54 (EX X4. % 6.58/6.54 ((bnd_event Y X4 & bnd_agent Y X4 X3) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_present Y X4) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_smoke Y X4))) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_of X5 Z X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_man X5 X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_jules_forename X5 Z) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_forename X5 Z) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_man X5 X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_state X5 X2) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_be X5 X2 X1 X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_proposition X5 X9) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_agent X5 X8 X1) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_theme X5 X8 X9) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_event X5 X8) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_present X5 X8) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_think_believe_consider X5 X8) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_accessible_world X5 X9) & % 6.58/6.54 (EX X10. % 6.58/6.54 ((bnd_event X9 X10 & bnd_agent X9 X10 V) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_present X9 X10) & % 6.58/6.54 bnd_smoke X9 X10)))) % 7.87/7.87 Unfolded term: [| ALL U V W X Y Z. % 7.87/7.87 ((((((bnd_think_believe_consider U V & bnd_proposition U Y) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_theme U V Y) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_agent U V X) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_think_believe_consider U W) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_proposition U Z) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_theme U W Z) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_agent U W X --> % 7.87/7.87 Y = Z; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W X. bnd_be U V W X --> W = X; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 (bnd_entity U V & bnd_forename U W) & bnd_of U W V --> % 7.87/7.87 ~ (EX X. (bnd_forename U X & ~ X = W) & bnd_of U X V); % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_smoke V U --> bnd_smoke W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_event V U --> bnd_event W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_eventuality V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_eventuality W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_thing V U --> bnd_thing W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_singleton V U --> bnd_singleton W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_specific V U --> bnd_specific W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_nonexistent V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_nonexistent W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_unisex V U --> bnd_unisex W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_present V U --> bnd_present W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W X. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world W X & bnd_agent W U V --> bnd_agent X U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_think_believe_consider V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_think_believe_consider W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W X. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world W X & bnd_theme W U V --> bnd_theme X U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_proposition V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_proposition W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_relation V U --> bnd_relation W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_abstraction V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_abstraction W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_nonhuman V U --> bnd_nonhuman W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_general V U --> bnd_general W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W X Y. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world X Y & bnd_be X U V W --> bnd_be Y U V W; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_state V U --> bnd_state W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_man V U --> bnd_man W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_human_person V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_human_person W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_organism V U --> bnd_organism W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_entity V U --> bnd_entity W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_existent V U --> bnd_existent W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_impartial V U --> bnd_impartial W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_living V U --> bnd_living W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_human V U --> bnd_human W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_animate V U --> bnd_animate W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_male V U --> bnd_male W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_forename V U --> bnd_forename W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_relname V U --> bnd_relname W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_vincent_forename V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_vincent_forename W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W X. bnd_accessible_world W X & bnd_of W U V --> bnd_of X U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V W. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world V W & bnd_jules_forename V U --> % 7.87/7.87 bnd_jules_forename W U; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_unisex U V --> ~ bnd_male U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_specific U V --> ~ bnd_general U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_nonhuman U V --> ~ bnd_human U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_existent U V --> ~ bnd_nonexistent U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_smoke U V --> bnd_event U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_event U V --> bnd_eventuality U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_eventuality U V --> bnd_thing U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_thing U V --> bnd_singleton U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_eventuality U V --> bnd_specific U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_eventuality U V --> bnd_nonexistent U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_eventuality U V --> bnd_unisex U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_proposition U V --> bnd_relation U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_relation U V --> bnd_abstraction U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_abstraction U V --> bnd_thing U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_abstraction U V --> bnd_nonhuman U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_abstraction U V --> bnd_general U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_abstraction U V --> bnd_unisex U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_state U V --> bnd_eventuality U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_state U V --> bnd_event U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_man U V --> bnd_human_person U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_human_person U V --> bnd_organism U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_organism U V --> bnd_entity U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_entity U V --> bnd_thing U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_entity U V --> bnd_specific U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_entity U V --> bnd_existent U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_organism U V --> bnd_impartial U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_organism U V --> bnd_living U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_human_person U V --> bnd_human U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_human_person U V --> bnd_animate U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_man U V --> bnd_male U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_forename U V --> bnd_relname U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_relname U V --> bnd_relation U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_vincent_forename U V --> bnd_forename U V; % 7.87/7.87 ALL U V. bnd_jules_forename U V --> bnd_forename U V |] % 7.87/7.87 ==> ~ ((EX U. bnd_actual_world U & % 7.87/7.87 (EX V W X Y Z X1 X2. % 7.87/7.87 (((((((((((((((((bnd_of U W V & bnd_man U V) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_vincent_forename U W) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_forename U W) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_proposition U Y) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_agent U X V) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_theme U X Y) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_event U X) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_present U X) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_think_believe_consider U X) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world U Y) & % 7.87/7.87 (ALL X3. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_man Y X3 --> % 7.87/7.87 (EX X4. % 7.87/7.87 ((bnd_event Y X4 & bnd_agent Y X4 X3) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_present Y X4) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_smoke Y X4))) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_of U Z X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_man U X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_jules_forename U Z) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_forename U Z) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_man U X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_state U X2) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_be U X2 X1 X1)) & % 7.87/7.87 ~ (EX X5. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_actual_world X5 & % 7.87/7.87 (EX X6 X7 V W X Y Z X1 X2 X8 X9. % 7.87/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((bnd_of X5 X6 V & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_jules_forename X5 X6) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_forename X5 X6) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_of X5 X7 X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_vincent_forename X5 X7) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_forename X5 X7) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_of X5 W V) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_man X5 V) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_vincent_forename X5 W) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_forename X5 W) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_proposition X5 Y) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_agent X5 X V) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_theme X5 X Y) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_event X5 X) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_present X5 X) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_think_believe_consider X5 X) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world X5 Y) & % 7.87/7.87 (ALL X3. % 7.87/7.87 bnd_man Y X3 --> % 7.87/7.87 (EX X4. % 7.87/7.87 ((bnd_event Y X4 & bnd_agent Y X4 X3) & bnd_present Y X4) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_smoke Y X4))) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_of X5 Z X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_man X5 X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_jules_forename X5 Z) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_forename X5 Z) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_man X5 X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_state X5 X2) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_be X5 X2 X1 X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_proposition X5 X9) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_agent X5 X8 X1) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_theme X5 X8 X9) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_event X5 X8) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_present X5 X8) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_think_believe_consider X5 X8) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_accessible_world X5 X9) & % 7.87/7.87 (EX X10. % 7.87/7.87 ((bnd_event X9 X10 & bnd_agent X9 X10 V) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_present X9 X10) & % 7.87/7.87 bnd_smoke X9 X10)))) % 7.87/7.87 Adding axioms... % 7.87/7.87 Typedef.type_definition_def % 16.69/16.68 ...done. % 16.69/16.69 Ground types: ?'b, TPTP_Interpret.ind % 16.69/16.69 Translating term (sizes: 1, 1) ... % 22.69/22.69 Invoking SAT solver... % 22.69/22.69 No model exists. % 22.69/22.69 Translating term (sizes: 2, 1) ... % 29.50/29.42 Invoking SAT solver... % 29.50/29.42 No model exists. % 29.50/29.42 Translating term (sizes: 1, 2) ... %------------------------------------------------------------------------------