%------------------------------------------------------------------------------ % File : Nitpick---2016 % Problem : SYN001^4.004 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v4.0.0. % Transfm : none % Format : tptp:raw % Command : isabelle tptp_nitpick %d %s % Computer : n136.star.cs.uiowa.edu % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 2.40GHz % Memory : 32218.75MB % OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.36.3.el7.x86_64 % CPULimit : 300s % DateTime : Wed Jan 18 18:45:55 EST 2017 % Result : CounterSatisfiable 27.27s % Output : FiniteModel 27.27s % Verified : % SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails) % Syntax : Number of formulae : 0 % Comments : %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation %------------------------------------------------------------------------------ %----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT % 0.00/0.03 % Problem : SYN001^4.004 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v4.0.0. % 0.00/0.04 % Command : isabelle tptp_nitpick %d %s % 0.03/0.23 % Computer : n136.star.cs.uiowa.edu % 0.03/0.23 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 % 0.03/0.23 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 @ 2.40GHz % 0.03/0.23 % Memory : 32218.75MB % 0.03/0.23 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.36.3.el7.x86_64 % 0.03/0.23 % CPULimit : 300 % 0.03/0.23 % DateTime : Mon Jan 16 00:39:33 CST 2017 % 0.03/0.23 % CPUTime: % 27.27/16.89 Nitpicking formula... % 27.27/16.89 Timestamp: 00:39:42 % 27.27/16.89 Using SAT solver "Lingeling_JNI" The following solvers are configured: % 27.27/16.89 "Lingeling_JNI", "CryptoMiniSat_JNI", "MiniSat_JNI", "SAT4J", "SAT4J_Light" % 27.27/16.89 Batch 1 of 20: Trying 5 scopes: % 27.27/16.89 card TPTP_Interpret.ind = 1 % 27.27/16.89 card TPTP_Interpret.ind = 2 % 27.27/16.89 card TPTP_Interpret.ind = 3 % 27.27/16.89 card TPTP_Interpret.ind = 4 % 27.27/16.89 card TPTP_Interpret.ind = 5 % 27.27/16.89 % SZS status CounterSatisfiable % SZS output start FiniteModel % 27.27/16.89 Nitpick found a counterexample for card TPTP_Interpret.ind = 2: % 27.27/16.89 % 27.27/16.89 Skolem constants: % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_ivalid.W = i1 % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i1) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i1 % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i1 % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i1 % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i1 % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i1) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i1), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i1)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i1) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i1) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i1 % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i2, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb Yc. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2))) % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.89 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i1 % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.89 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.89 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.89 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.89 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.90 \<lambda>Ya Yb. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = % 27.27/16.90 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.90 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2), % 27.27/16.90 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2)) % 27.27/16.90 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.90 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.90 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.90 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.90 ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = i2 % 27.27/16.90 \<lambda>Ya. ??.bnd_mbox_s4.Y = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := i1, i2 := i2) % 27.27/16.90 Constants: % 27.27/16.90 bnd_a1 = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := False, i2 := True) % 27.27/16.90 bnd_a2 = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := True, i2 := True) % 27.27/16.90 bnd_a3 = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := True, i2 := True) % 27.27/16.90 bnd_a4 = (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := True, i2 := True) % 27.27/16.90 bnd_irel = % 27.27/16.90 (\<lambda>x. _) % 27.27/16.90 (i1 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := True, i2 := True), % 27.27/16.90 i2 := (\<lambda>x. _)(i1 := False, i2 := True)) % 27.27/16.90 % SZS output end FiniteModel % 27.27/16.90 Total time: 5.7 s %------------------------------------------------------------------------------